thewaronporn

The War on Porn was created because of the long standing assault on free speech in the form of sexual expression that is porn and adult content.

Federal Judge Weighs Challenge to Texas Pornography Health Warning Law

Texas flag

AUSTIN, Texas — Competing motions for summary judgment have been filed in a federal court in Texas over a state law requiring age verification on adult websites and mandating health warnings about pornography, with both sides seeking a ruling from the judge on the law’s constitutionality.

The filings were submitted by adult industry plaintiffs challenging the state and by the office of outgoing Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton. Both sides are seeking a decision from U.S. District Judge David Alan Ezra, a Reagan-era appointee.

The dispute stems from the original court proceedings in 2023 and involves Texas House Bill 1181, the state’s age-verification law. The legislation reached the U.S. Supreme Court in 2025, where justices upheld the constitutionality of age verification. However, litigation continued in Texas over other provisions of the law, including its requirements for websites beyond the age-gating provisions.

The latest proceedings involve a challenge brought by the Free Speech Coalition (FSC), an adult industry trade association, along with parent companies of several major adult tube sites. The plaintiffs are contesting HB 1181’s age-verification provisions and its requirement that adult websites display public health warnings about the purported effects of pornography consumption.

Earlier in the case, Judge Ezra, a senior judge in the Western District of Texas, found that the mandated health warnings likely violated the First and Fourteenth Amendments. The ruling centered on the disputed nature of the claims the law requires websites to communicate.

Courts evaluating government-mandated speech by private businesses apply legal standards to determine whether such requirements are permissible. One of those tests is the Zauderer standard, which examines when the government can compel commercial speech without infringing on First Amendment protections.

Under HB 1181, adult websites accessible to Texas users would be required to display health-related warnings intended to inform visitors about alleged risks associated with pornography consumption.

The law requires adult websites with users in Texas to prominently display the mandated public health warnings. Lawmakers included language asserting potential health consequences associated with pornography use, similar to warnings placed on alcohol, cigarette and vaping products.

Judge Ezra previously struck down the warning requirements, citing concerns that they failed to satisfy the Zaudererstandard. Under that test, compelled disclosures must be “purely factual and uncontroversial.”

Ezra found that the warnings did not meet that threshold, noting the absence of a recognized medical diagnosis for pornography addiction and a lack of sufficient scientific evidence supporting the claims included in the mandated notices. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that portion of his ruling. In their latest filing, the FSC and other plaintiffs are asking Ezra to grant summary judgment based on his earlier findings.

“The requirement of HB 1181 to post health warnings and a helpline notice is not a valid exercise of the state’s power to regulate speech (commercial or otherwise), and Texas cannot constitutionally turn adult websites into government billboards waging its own war against adult content,” the attorneys for the adult industry plaintiffs argue. “The court should enter summary judgment for the plaintiffs.”

Attorneys for Paxton’s office take a different position, citing research and testimony from anti-pornography advocates in support of the law’s disputed health claims. Court filings show the state relied on academics, including political scientist Vanessa Bouché, who co-authored research with other anti-pornography scholars published in the journal Dignity.

The journal has faced criticism over its academic standards and research practices, as well as controversy surrounding editor-in-chief Donna M. Hughes, a University of Rhode Island professor of gender and women’s studies who has been accused of anti-trans views. Other experts retained by Paxton’s office include feminist activist Gail Dines, founder of Culture Reframed, a group associated with anti-pornography advocacy.

The FSC and other plaintiffs have countered with experts who say the scientific evidence does not support the health warnings required by the law. Dr. Joshua Grubbs, an associate professor of psychology at the University of New Mexico, wrote in a report submitted on behalf of the plaintiffs that the warnings contain “a veritable cavalcade of misconceptions, misdirection, and false claims.”

“In my expert opinion, the inclusion of such warnings would likely be actively harmful to users of such adult websites, as it would promote false beliefs about pornography use and sexual behavior that would likely lead to feelings of distress and confusion among users,” Grubbs wrote.

Attorney Corey Silverstein, who represents adult industry clients, said he expects the plaintiffs to prevail on their request for summary judgment.

“Once a visitor has verified that they’re an adult, how does requiring a mental health and substance use helpline on every page they visit keep a child from seeing the content? I think the court should make the injunction against the warnings permanent,” Silverstein said.

The FSC’s co-plaintiffs, WebGroup Czech Republic and NKL Associates, which own and operate Xvideos and XNXX, have also asked the court to rule that both the health warning and age-verification provisions of HB 1181 violate the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause because they conflict with Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996.

“The Fifth Circuit already reasoned that the state can impose liability for a platform’s own failure to check a visitor’s age without proving that anyone was harmed by a user’s upload,” Silverstein concluded. “That’s why I expect a split ruling, with the warnings blocked and the age-verification requirement still in force.”

Read More »

Indiana Judge Dismisses AG’s Lawsuit Against Aylo

Indiana flag

INDIANAPOLIS — An Indiana judge has dismissed a lawsuit brought by Republican Attorney General Todd Rokita against Aylo, the parent company of Pornhub.com, and several affiliated businesses.

Rokita filed the lawsuit last December against Aylo and its ownership group, Ottawa-based Ethical Capital Partners, alleging that the companies violated Indiana’s age-verification law (AVL) by failing to prevent users from bypassing geographic restrictions through virtual private networks (VPNs), which can mask a user’s actual location.

The case was filed in Marion Superior Court in Indianapolis. In March, Aylo’s attorneys sought dismissal of the lawsuit, challenging the claims brought by Rokita’s office.

Judge Patrick J. Dietrick dismissed all claims brought by the attorney general’s office, including allegations that Aylo and its affiliated platforms failed to restrict access to users located in Indiana when VPNs or proxy servers were used to make their IP addresses appear to originate outside the state.

Rokita’s office argued that VPNs provide minors with a means of accessing content otherwise restricted under Indiana’s age-verification requirements. However, the state did not establish that VPN use constituted a violation of the law, a point addressed in Dietrick’s ruling.

“An AVL claim requires facts showing that the defendant (1) owns or operates a publicly accessible website (2) on which at least one-third of the images and videos depict material harmful to minors, (3) knowingly or intentionally publishes it, and (4) does not use a reasonable age verification method,” Dietrick wrote.

“The AVL contains no provision based on a user’s physical location and none addressing VPNs or proxy servers, and courts ‘may not add new words to a statute which are not the expressed intent of the legislature,'” he added.

During the investigation preceding the lawsuit, an investigator working for Rokita’s office used a commercially available VPN service to make the internet connection appear to originate in Chicago. The judge’s ruling also addressed the implications of that test for the state’s claims and its attempt to establish jurisdiction in Indiana.

“The claim against Aylo Premium and Aylo Social fails for the same reason,” Dietrick explained. “Every alleged instance of access to a paysite or marketplace site came through a Chicago IP address.”

He further wrote, “The state’s theory that defendants know VPNs can defeat IP-based restrictions alleges at most general awareness that geolocation sometimes fails, not knowledge that a particular user presenting an Illinois IP address is physically in Indiana.”

“On the facts the Complaint itself pleads, no operator knowingly or intentionally published adult content without age verification to a user it identified as being in Indiana, and the Complaint identifies no defect in what Aylo Premium or Aylo Social presents to such users,” Dietrick concluded.

A spokesperson for Aylo was contacted for comment but had not responded by the time of publication.

Read More »

Is the UK Going to Criminalize Adult Creators for ‘Exploiting’ Themselves? By Stan Q. Brick

UK flag

As you already know if you’re a regular reader of this site, a group of MPs in the United Kingdom is calling for the criminalization of adult webcamming, terming it “e-pimping” and asserting that “harms relating to the webcamming trade are severe and wide-ranging, affecting all women and girls – whether they are directly involved in the trade or not.”

The claim that adult webcamming harms all women is the sort of sweeping assertion we always hear when it comes to sexually explicit expression, which to hear the most zealous decency crusaders tell it has been absolutely ruining society since the inception of pornography, back when prehistoric humans began scrawling dick pics on the walls of caves.

As someone who has spent over half his life working in the adult industry, I’m not going to sit here and claim exploitation never happens in this line of work. Frankly, it would be insane to claim any industry is free of exploitation.

Where I strongly dispute the findings of the All-Party Group on Commercial Sexual Exploitation (APGCSE), the name for the group of MPs who are calling for webcamming to be outlawed, is the notion that the technology and camming industry vertical are inherently exploitative or necessarily making things worse.

For starters, modern adult performers and content creators have a vastly increased number of options for how they work within the adult industry compared to earlier generations. The days of a handful of adult studios or a few dozen online companies serving as publishing gatekeepers are long gone.

Whether webcam networks and platforms like OnlyFans and its competitors are exploiting their creators by taking too large a slice of the sales revenue, selectively enforcing their content policies, selectively shadowbanning people or any other sort of poor corporate behavior likely varies from site to site – and opinions of those platforms among creators certainly vary quite a bit, as well.

One gets the sense that would-be censors like the APGCSE aren’t particularly interested in nuance or distinguishing between good and bad corporate citizens among adult platforms, though. They’re convinced of their moral superiority and the righteousness of their paternalistic orientation to the point they’re not going to hesitate to toss out the creators’ personal income baby along with the platform’s allegedly exploitative bathwater.

I’d also point out that while the APGCSE report makes repeated reference to OnlyFans and to webcamming platforms (News Flash: camming is not exactly the core of OnlyFans’ business), many of the specific examples of alleged exploitation highlighted in the report involve OnlyFans management agencies – or indeed, individual managers.

The report is a bit more persuasive in the sections describing sexual exploitation by studios, abusive partners and viewers – but again, the things described in those sections are already illegal. Cracking down directly on companies and individuals who exploit performers seems a more promising approach to addressing the problems cited in the report, as it can be done without punishing the creators, managers, agencies, studios, viewers and others who aren’t engaging in those crimes.

There’s no question OnlyFans and platforms like it have their issues. But they’re also places where a lot of women (and men and trans folk) are earning good money on their own images and content. I suppose the APGCSE might respond that even if a creator is performing each sex act willingly, they are still engaged in an act of self-exploitation, which is harming them in ways of which they may not be aware – in addition to damaging everyone else in society, as the APGCSE report asserts right up front.

But should this sort of “self-exploitation” truly be a government’s concern? If so, does the UK government also have a paternalistic role to play in regulating entertainment like football? People sometimes DIE from playing that game, after all. And just like its American football counterpart, the game most of the rest of the world calls football produces a whole lot of concussions.

To be clear, I’m not calling for the UK to ban football. Among other things, if they do that, I’ll have a lot less to look forward to over the course of nine months of each year, even though for me, watching the Premier League sometimes means getting up at 4:30am on a Saturday.

All I’m saying, again, is that if you believe women are full human beings, with independent agency and a right to self-determination, then it makes no sense to deprive them of options for employment, competition, income generation, entertainment or any other facet of life, under reasoning of the sort we never seem to apply to men.

Certainly, we should all be against exploitation. But there are smart and effective ways to fight exploitation and there are overreaching, one-size-fits-all, censorship campaigns masquerading as anti-exploitation efforts. If you’ve read this far, you already know which sort of campaign I believe APGCSE to be waging.

Read More »

Irish PM Reaffirms Support for U.K.-Style Pornography Ban

Irish flag

DUBLIN, Ireland—The Irish Government reiterated on Wednesday its support for legislation restricting certain categories of pornography, saying the proposed measures would bring the country’s laws closer to those recently introduced in England and Wales.

Prime Minister Micheál Martin told the Dáil Éireann, the lower house of the Irish Parliament, that the government needed to address what he described as the “violent nature of this pornographic material.” Martin was responding to questions from members of the Dáil, known as deputies, about government efforts to regulate pornography depicting BDSM, kink and consensual choking.

In May, Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan announced that his department was preparing legislation modeled on provisions adopted in the United Kingdom.

The proposed measures would target material classified by O’Callaghan and the government as “extreme or violent” pornography, making the possession, production and distribution of such content criminal offenses. Deputy Naoise Ó Muirí opened the latest parliamentary debate by arguing that there was an “urgent need for legislation to address the role that exposure to extreme pornographic material is playing in normalising sexual violence and harmful sexual behaviour among young people.

“There is growing recognition across the world that violence and extreme pornography is both highly accessible and increasingly influential,” Ó Muiri added. “It is shaping attitudes about sex, relationships and consent, particularly among young people.”

Martin responded, “In short, the government is responding in an affirmative way to the points he has raised.”

Martin continued, “First of all, we have a zero-tolerance approach to domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. It is a scourge on our society. The level of violence against women is very serious. We want to ensure that all victims and survivors can access the support, protection and justice they require.”

He said Justice Minister O’Callaghan had “secured government approval to commence [the] drafting … [of the bill] for the inclusion in the general scheme of the criminal law (sexual offences, domestic violence, and international instruments) bill.” The proposed restrictions on pornography classified as violent or extreme are therefore expected to come before lawmakers for consideration in the coming months.

“This bill will create offences relating to the possession, production and distribution of violent or extreme pornography, addressing a significant gap in Irish law,” Martin said. “It is contributing to misogynistic attitudes but also to violence.”

In the United Kingdom, the Crime and Policing Act, passed by Parliament this year, established criminal penalties, including potential prison sentences, for producing, watching or possessing certain types of pornography involving consenting adults engaged in age-play or consensual choking. The provisions took effect on Nov. 6, extending the reach of the UK’s restrictions and drawing attention from adult entertainment industry stakeholders in the United States and other countries.

Read More »

U.K. Lawmakers Push to Criminalize Camming, Calling It ‘E-pimping’

UK flag

LONDON—A new report from a group of U.K. parliamentarians is calling for online camming platforms and the practice of “e-pimping” to be outlawed and criminalized, days after the country began enforcing a controversial ban on certain pornography categories that carries substantial financial and criminal penalties.

In a report titled “Only Exploitation,” members of the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Sexual and Commercial Sexual Exploitation argue that the multibillion-dollar live camming industry should be prohibited in the United Kingdom, with activities associated with it made criminal offenses.

“The webcamming trade is a magnet for exploiters,” said Labor MP Tracy Gilbert, chair of the group and a co-author of the report.

“These e-pimps style themselves as legitimate ‘managers’ and agencies, yet they exert sexual coercion and control over the women they recruit and profit from,” Gilbert added.

The 40-page report, published through the group’s secretariat, U.K. Feminista, a nonprofit organization that opposes the commercial sex industry, mentions OnlyFans 50 times. OnlyFans is operated by Fenix International Limited, which is based in London’s Cheapside district. The report also identifies what it describes as “five main harms perpetrated against women and children via webcamming platforms.” These include sexual coercion, intimate image abuse, security and privacy risks, offline sexual exploitation and child sexual exploitation.

Gilbert said, “Webcamming platforms are a form of commercial sexual exploitation. The level of risk and severity of harms attached to their activities is unacceptable. We are urging the Government to confront online sex trafficking and sexual exploitation by outlawing e-pimping and preventing commercial online platforms from live-streaming pornography and prostitution.”

The report, co-authored by fellow Labor MP Tonia Antoniazzi, does not provide a definition of “e-pimping.” The term has no established definition under common law in either the United States or the United Kingdom and is not currently recognized as a criminal or civil offense. Nevertheless, the APPG authors have proposed several legislative changes that would establish new offenses.

Among the recommendations are defining e-pimping in national law and making it a criminal offense. The report also proposes criminal liability for online platforms that “enable or profit from commercial live streaming of pornography and prostitution.” Another recommendation calls for classifying e-pimping as a “human trafficking” offense.

“Law enforcement and organisations with designated regulatory powers and functions must be able to access all content hosted and streamed by pornography platforms for investigative and enforcement purposes,” states another recommendation. The report’s authors also propose that “enforcement against the distribution of illegal pornographic content, including via webcamming platforms, must be strengthened via improved monitoring, training and leadership.”

Alison Boden, a self-described feminist and executive director of the Free Speech Coalition, told AVN that she strongly objects to the report’s recommendations.

“This report is nothing more than an anti-porn activist group’s press release on parliamentary letterhead,” Boden said. “These self-proclaimed feminists don’t trust women to make their own choices; they don’t trust women to make their own decisions; so of course they didn’t include the voice of a single working [cam] performer.”

“Unfortunately, this blatant call for censorship can’t be ignored at a time when U.K. lawmakers seem determined to police everything adults see and do online,” Boden added.

Live camming is one of the fastest-growing and most profitable segments of online adult entertainment. It has also been identified in research as a potentially safer form of sex work compared with in-person arrangements.

A 2018 study, conducted by researchers at the University of Leicester in England found that online sex work, including camming, can offer safer working conditions than in-person meetings.

Millions of people worldwide work in online sex-related professions, with the United States and the United Kingdom among the largest consumer markets for camming

Read More »

Will the ‘Blue Wave’ Slow the March of Internet Regulation? Probably Not – By Morley Safeword

US Flag

Over the decades I’ve been part of the online adult entertainment industry, the internet has gone from being essentially unregulated to an increasingly regulated space, particularly where sexually explicit content is concerned.

Thirty years ago, as a guy working for a company that operated both free and subscription adult sites, my primary legal concerns were the seemingly remote possibility of being prosecuted for obscenity law violations and the far more likely possibility of being sued in civil court for something like copyright infringement, should one of our designers ever get carried away and use content for which our company didn’t hold the rights.

Over the decades, I think it’s fair to say the prevailing sense among people in the online adult sector has been that Republican administrations present a greater risk of obscenity law enforcement, especially at the federal level.

That belief has largely been supported by the evidence over the years, as federal obscenity cases involving adult material (as opposed to child pornography cases, which every Justice Department rightfully prosecutes vigorously) were just about nonexistent under the Clinton Administration, after being commonplace under the George H.W. Bush Administration.

After George W. Bush took the White House in 2000, obscenity prosecutions were once again pursued, including cases that carried over beyond his term in office. During the Obama Administration, the Obscenity Prosecution Task Force (OPTF), created in 2005 and responsible for prosecuting adult obscenity cases under the George W. Bush administration, was dissolved.

These days, the possibility of being prosecuted for an obscenity crime probably doesn’t often enter the minds of adult site operators, in part because unlike his Republican predecessors, Donald Trump has shown little interest in prosecuting adult obscenity cases. I’m sure if James Comey ever launches a porn site, Trump will develop a sudden interest in prosecuting at least one obscenity case, but short of that, I don’t think a reestablishment of the OPTF is imminent – regardless of any pledge Trump once signed to the contrary.

While obscenity prosecutions might not be occupying much mental space for adult entrepreneurs these days, the online space is otherwise much more closely regulated than it once was. The proliferation of age verification laws across the U.S., fines doled out by Ofcom in the United Kingdom and similar developmentselsewhere in Europe show the extent to which governments have imposed their will on the once freewheeling internet.

Last week’s midterm elections in the United States could lead to sweeping policy changes in a variety of areas, especially those which newly elected Democrats believe are important to the voters who elected them. And while I’d like to think reasonable regulation of online spaces and a show of restraint with respect to laws that impact freedom of expression online is both important to the voters who created the “Blue Wave,” I certainly don’t have any polling data to back up that notion.

I’ve also been around long enough to come to grips with the realization that some things I think are bad ideas, or good ideas executed badly, also happen to be politically popular –or even enjoy bipartisan political popularity, a very rare thing in the deeply divided modern electorate.

Unfortunately for those who believe things like age verification laws offer more downside than upside (at least as they are currently structured and enforced), these laws have largely sailed through state legislatures, in part because they present legislators with an opportunity to vote for something that’s popular and relatively noncontroversial.

The bottom line, ever since I first became aware of how politics, law and the adult industry interact, has been this: Our industry has very few friends in Washington. Hell, we don’t even have enough friends in Phoenix to make a difference. And in the case of the Grand Canyon State’s capital, it hasn’t been for lack of trying

Back in May of 2025, Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs signed HB 2112, bringing into force the state’s age verification law. During the debate and drafting process, the bill met with staunch opposition, led in part by the adult industry trade association, Free Speech Coalition.

As FSC noted in a statement released when Hobbs signed the bill, the organization “led the fight against the bill since it was introduced in January, testifying against it repeatedly in committee, meeting with Republican and Democratic legislators in Arizona and building a broad-based coalition.”  FSC Director of Public Policy Mike Stabile was “a constant figure in Phoenix” during the year running up to the vote on the bill, “securing near-universal Democratic opposition to the bill despite heavy political headwinds in the state,” FSC added.

Obviously, Hobbs then signed the bill anyway, a development that left FSC “disappointed,” as the organization put it, a term far more measured than those they probably wanted to use, given the lobbying effort FSC had put in.

I’m not suggesting all political lobbying is in vain, or that organizations like FSC should simply throw in the towel. I’m just saying, based on decades of experience, the disappointment the FSC felt at Gov. Hobbs isn’t a new sensation. It’s also one we’re not likely to avoid feeling again in response to many legislative sessions to come, whether the states involved are red, blue, or purple.

Read More »

U.K. Begins Enforcing Criminal Prohibitions on ‘Taboo’ Pornography

Big Ben

LONDON—British law enforcement and regulatory agencies are beginning enforcement of new prohibitions on several categories of pornography criminalized under legislation introduced with the stated aim of protecting women and minors.

The U.K. Parliament approved key provisions of the Crime and Policing Act 2026, which prohibit certain categories of pornography, including material that may be legally produced through consensual adult performances in countries with broader freedom of expression protections, such as the United States, the world’s largest consumer market for the adult entertainment industry.

The enforcement measures are intended to address “the harm that some forms of pornography can have in shaping real-world behavior.”

“These restrictions are outrageous and represent a ridiculous expansion of government control over sexual expression,” observed adult entertainment industry lawyer Corey Silverstein in an interview. “Extending criminal liability to certain staged depictions involving consenting adults raises fundamental questions about how far the state should be permitted to police adult fantasy and private possession.”

The penalties for violating the new provisions are substantial, according to details released by the U.K. Ministry of Justice last month. Offenders could face significant fines and prison sentences.

“These offenses, which carry up to five years’ imprisonment for publication, also become priority illegal content under the Online Safety Act, imposing proactive duties on platforms,” noted adult industry attorney Lawrence Walters in an interview.

The Crime and Policing Act 2026 specifically prohibits several categories of pornography and adult content, including depictions of choking, age-play and certain types of “step-family” content.

Implementation and enforcement will involve several organizations within the U.K.’s media regulatory and criminal justice systems, including digital regulator Ofcom, the Ministry of Justice, the British Board of Film Classification, local police forces and the Crown Prosecution Service.

Ofcom will oversee the regulatory framework and enforcement standards, including communicating the new restrictions to industry members and consumers while continuing to implement the requirements established under the Online Safety Act. Walters noted that the legislation also expands the regulator’s authority.

“The rules reach consensual adult role-play that remains lawful in the United States and elsewhere, creating extraterritorial risk and uncertainty under the ‘reasonable person’ standard,” Walters warned. The reasonable person standard is a legal principle used in common-law jurisdictions, including the United Kingdom and the United States, to assess conduct and determine potential negligence, liability and intent in civil and criminal proceedings.

“Operators that limit U.K. access to or sale of the prohibited material will be best positioned to continue serving other markets while managing elevated legal and regulatory exposure,” Walters concluded. He said the expanded regulatory powers granted to Ofcom could lead adult websites and platforms to consider measures such as comprehensive geographic restrictions.

The Crime and Policing Act also changes Ofcom’s regulatory role, giving it greater responsibility for proactive oversight rather than primarily responding to violations. Its regulatory and policymaking activities will now incorporate expanded definitions of unlawful content, including material depicting consenting adults.

“Pornographic content depicting strangulation, role-playing as a child and incest is now illegal online,” an Ofcom spokesperson said in an email. “This means individuals can be prosecuted by law enforcement for possessing or publishing this material.”

The spokesperson added, “New legal duties on tech firms to deal with this content will come into force once we have updated our codes of practice and guidance—as required by law—and we’re preparing to consult on this in the first half of 2027.”

Ofcom has not provided a specific timetable for the consultations or clarified which individuals and organizations will be invited to participate. With questions remaining about how the new restrictions will be interpreted and enforced, adult industry companies are taking precautionary steps. Several platforms are revising their terms and conditions and advising creators and producers to pay attention to the legislative changes taking effect and the potential regulatory requirements ahead.

Aylo, the parent company of Pornhub, confirmed that it intends to comply with the new restrictions affecting content available in the United Kingdom. The company also plans to participate in the public consultations Ofcom is expected to organize.

“Aylo intends to actively and constructively participate in any upcoming public consultations hosted by Ofcom to help see that the implementation of the law will be done in the safest possible manner,” an Aylo spokesperson said, adding, “Ofcom is taking the necessary time in order to issue official regulatory guidance and compliance frameworks for these new mandates.

“Once these are formalized and issued, we will review them and make any necessary adjustments to our standards,” the spokesperson concluded. “Aylo already maintains stringent policies to prohibit illegal or dangerous material on its platforms.”

The legislation affects adult tube sites and user-generated content platforms, including OnlyFans, Fansly, MintStars, DarkFans, Clips4Sale, FetLife and Justfor.fans. Its reach also extends to other services hosting niche or fetish content, regardless of whether performers have provided explicit consent or supplied documentation confirming their legal age. Mainstream social media platforms, including X, Reddit and Bluesky, are also covered by the new requirements.

Mike Stabile, director of public policy for the Free Speech Coalition, an adult entertainment industry trade association, said the enforcement of the new restrictions presents an unfamiliar legal situation for the United Kingdom.

“The law is vague and we don’t know what to expect from enforcement,” Stabile explained. “We don’t know what content they plan to come after, we don’t know how they plan to come after it, who they plan to come after, or even who we expect to prosecute it.

“The law gives the government sweeping powers to prosecute both distribution and possession, but as with most censorship laws, the decision to prosecute is often subjective and arbitrary,” he added. “Creators, platforms and fans are all subject to the law, and the scope of potential content is wide. Should we expect police to show up at a creator’s house or at the offices of X? Should fans expect their devices to be searched at the border for offending content?”

Stabile said the legislation does not establish a clear enforcement framework and questioned whether its provisions could be applied consistently and equally.

“This all seems far fetched, but the truth is we don’t know,” Stabile concluded. “Normally, we’d expect this to be handled through Ofcom, which has said it’s still working on guidance. But this is a moral panic, and it’s unclear what pressure will be brought and against whom.”

Performers have also been asked about how they plan to operate under the new legal requirements.

Among those interviewed, Candy Rose, a U.K.-based transgender content creator who recently attracted attention for organizing a protest involving multiple performers to highlight legislation affecting transgender and queer people in the country, discussed the potential consequences for adult creators and consumers. Rose said she understands some of the arguments behind the restrictions but believes their practical effects could extend beyond the intended targets.

“I think some of the new U.K. pornography legislation is becoming increasingly extreme,” Rose explained. “While I can appreciate the reasoning behind certain measures, I think policymakers are missing a much wider conversation.”

Rose added, “Firstly, we need to distinguish between exploitative, abusive or non-consensual material and content produced between consenting adults. In legitimate adult productions, performers are adults who have willingly agreed to participate, with consent agreements and contractual safeguards in place. Consent, of course, must be informed, freely given, and ongoing.”

Tighten repeated explanationsClarify the enforcement timelineRemove editorial wording

Read More »

Sometimes I Hate Being Right by Stan Q. Brick

New York State Capitol

For as long as I’ve been thinking and writing about online age verification, something that goes back to the early days of the online adult industry and a once-numerous category of platforms called “AVS” sites (which stood for Adult Verification Sites, as I recall), I’ve been telling people that once the government gained a foothold in restricting access to adult content online, legislative bodies would then seek to expand that foothold to encompass a wide variety of content types – and to broad categories of technology used to either create or consume content.

This is one of those instances when I’m very unhappy to have been proven right.

Late last week, New York Governor Kathy Hochul signed into law a measure that restricts the features AI chatbots can provide to minors – and to users whose adulthood has not been verified.

The new law specifies twelve varieties of “unsafe AI companion features,” a list which goes well beyond sexually explicit content – and well beyond the encouragement of self-harm, for that matter.

Under the law adopted by New York, AI chatbots are restricted from suggesting the chatbot is alive, human, capable of human emotions, or suggesting that there’s a personal or professional relationship between the user and the chatbot. The chatbots can’t suggest they have a role as an authority, cannot offer responses positioned as the chatbot’s own personal opinions or emotional appeals, nor can they offer flattery, or function as sycophants that might encourage or endorse awful lines of thought.

Some folks might read that and think it’s a reasonable list of restrictions. Hell, some might even wonder why the state would limit these protections to minors, given what we know about some truly terrible outcomes involving adult users of AI companions.

But the point here isn’t really whether this specific law is a good or bad idea; it’s that we all know this isn’t the end of the story. Considering the Supreme Court’s decision in FSC v. Paxton, courts across the country are already reconsidering past rulings that nixed other age verification measures, like those related to the SCOPE Act in Texas.

To be clear, I’m not against regulating AI. I’m not even against enacting specific restrictions pertaining to the use of AI by minors. What I’m against is the legislative version of “feature creep,” a phenomenon I believe we’re currently watching as it unfolds in real time.

The New York law has several rather expansive provisions, some of which might be well-intentioned, but are nonetheless problematic, both from a compliance perspective and as they relate to the First Amendment.

For example, the law restricts outputs “that constitute, describe, or facilitate sexually explicit conduct or child sexual abuse material,” as attorney Corey Silverstein noted in a recent newsletter alerting readers to the new law.

This too might sound reasonable at first glance. But suppose a minor asks an AI companion for advice on dealing with an abusive situation the minor is experiencing in the real world; will the chatbot be restricted to saying “Sorry, I can’t talk to you about that”? Can it direct the child to counselors, law enforcement and other resources which can help?

New York’s law was opposed by the Business Council of New York State – and the opposition wasn’t on the grounds that the BCNYS hates children or wants AI chatbots to be allowed to counsel minors to kill themselves. The Council opposed the legislation because “restrictions on ordinary conversational responses could affect educational tools, accessibility applications and general-purpose AI assistants.”

In May, the Council authored a memo arguing that the bill’s definitions are “overbroad and inconsistent with existing New York law.” The Council also asserted the prohibitions “would sweep in educational, research, and general-purpose tools that serve and benefit minors every day,” while its age-verification mandate “contradicts the bill’s own ‘actual knowledge’ standard and raises serious constitutional, privacy, and security concerns.” To top it off, the measure’s “liability framework imposes strict liability on non-deceptive conduct, and its enforcement mechanism — including a private right of action with punitive damages and disgorgement — creates unquantifiable litigation risk that would chill beneficial innovation.”

The Council also noted that an existing set of restrictions on AI chatbots, the New York AI Companions Act, has only been in effect since November 2025. There’s barely been time to measure the initial impact of that law, and already New York is adding layer upon layer over the top of it.

Again, none of this is to say I’m against regulating AI or restricting how minors use AI. My concern is that the more we regulate what minors can do with technologies like AI chatbots, the more we burden and complicate adults’ use of the same technologies. And while age verification measures generally are politically popular, how effective these measures will turn out to be is anyone’s guess. Thus far, regulations like the UK’s Online Safety Act don’t appear to be having much impact.

Right now, the government might be focused on AI chatbots, but what’s the next technology or form of expression to be crammed within the restrictive regulatory grasp of age verification? The possibilities are legion, because whether we like it or not, adults and children live in the same world.

While the rules of that shared world can’t be the same for minors and adults, maybe we ought to consider more deeply both what we’re giving up in the name of protecting minors – and whether those measures even work in the first place – before we go rushing adding to the list? Just a thought.

Read More »

Fifth Circuit to Rehear Challenge to Texas Age Verification Law

Gavel

NEW ORLEANS—The U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans, Louisiana, has agreed to reconsider its ruling on the Securing Children Online Through Parental Empowerment (SCOPE) Act, a broad Texas age verification law enacted in 2023.

In a court filing last week, Chief Judge Jennifer Walker Elrod granted a petition for the case to be reheard en banc, meaning by the full court. Such proceedings allow all active judges on a circuit court to review a case, rather than leaving the decision to a smaller panel. En banc reviews are relatively rare and typically occur when a case raises significant legal questions or concerns about a previous ruling.

The constitutional challenge to the SCOPE Act consists of two cases: Computer and Communications Industry Association & NetChoice v. Paxton and Students Engaged in Advancing Texas et al. v. Paxton. In both lawsuits, the plaintiffs argue that the law infringes on the rights of adult internet users by regulating how digital platforms interact with minors under the age of 18 in Texas.

The SCOPE Act was enacted and signed into law in 2023, with enforcement beginning on Sept. 1, 2024. It requires digital platforms to verify users’ ages and obtain verifiable parental consent before collecting personal information from minors or allowing them to create accounts.

The law also imposes age verification requirements across a broad range of digital services. According to guidance issued by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, a Republican currently running for the U.S. Senate in a competitive election, the law primarily applies to “digital services that provide an online platform for social interaction between users that … allow users to create a public or semi-public profile to use the service, and … allow users to create or post content that can be viewed by other users of the service.” The definition encompasses a wide range of online platforms and builds on existing state legislation, including House Bill 1181 and Senate Bill 2420.

HB 1181 established age verification requirements specifically targeting adult entertainment websites. The legislation prompted the Free Speech Coalition, an adult industry trade association, to file a lawsuit against Paxton and Texas, joined by the parent companies of several major adult websites. The case ultimately reached the U.S. Supreme Court, where the court’s conservative majority upheld the constitutionality of age verification requirements for pornography websites. SB 2420, known as the App Store Accountability Act, also reached the Supreme Court through an emergency application seeking to block its implementation, but the request was denied.

The SCOPE Act, also designated HB 18, extends to services including “digital services such as message boards, chat rooms, video channels, or a main feed that presents users [with] content created and posted by other users,” according to Paxton’s office. In an Oct. 28 ruling, Elrod vacated the court’s earlier decision and ordered that the case “shall be reheard by the court en banc with oral argument on a date hereafter to be fixed.”

The vacated decision was a panel opinion issued on July 24, 2026, which blocked a controversial content filtering provision of the SCOPE Act. The panel had found that the provision conflicted with federal law, specifically Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996.

Section 230, frequently described as the “First Amendment of the internet,” has played a central role in legal challenges to age verification legislation, including lawsuits involving HB 1181 and SB 2420. Elrod’s latest order, however, vacates the July 24 opinion, leaving the panel’s decision without effect as the full court prepares to reconsider the case.

Corey Silverstein, an attorney representing clients in the adult entertainment industry, said the latest developments warrant close attention from industry members.

“I see a substantial risk that the full Fifth Circuit will reverse or significantly narrow the panel’s Section 230 ruling,” Silverstein told AVN. “Granting rehearing signals that a majority of the active judges want to revisit the decision, although it does not establish how they will ultimately vote.

“For the adult industry, the concern extends beyond this particular Texas law,” he added. “A ruling that narrows Section 230 protection for content moderation could encourage other states to impose their own filtering mandates. I would take the threat of an adverse ruling seriously, while recognizing that Texas still faces meaningful legal obstacles.”

Remove the unnecessary election referenceClarify the timeline of the rulings

Read More »

FSC Issues Guidance on New U.K. Porn Legislation

Ofcom logo

LOS ANGELES — The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has released new guidance for members on United Kingdom laws affecting the production of pornography. The guidance outlines key details of the legislation and its implications for adult industry professionals working in the UK.
Here is the guidance from the FSC website:

The Free Speech Coalition has published guidance dealing with the UK law criminalizing certain choking, roleplay and age play content. While more detailed regulatory guidance is still expected from organizations like Ofcom, the law officially goes into effect November 6.

While the law is vague, we’ve attempted to parse the various provisions and the potential risk they can create for our members” says Alison Boden, Executive Director of Free Speech Coalition. “FSC can’t provide legal advice, but we hope to provide context and clarity to help cut through some of the misinformation online. These are draconian bans with serious penalties for creators, platforms and consumers, and FSC members should take the law seriously.”

The new law criminalizes distribution and possession of consensual sexual material, enforced through potentially enormous fines from Ofcom, as well as criminal charges.

Because everyone’s situation is unique and the lines between what is now legal and illegal somewhat arbitrary, FSC urges industry members to speak to a UK lawyer to review their content and study their potential liability.

While individuals and businesses based in the UK likely face the greatest immediate risk, anyone with material accessible in the UK faces potential exposure. All businesses that publish or store content in the UK should review the law, be aware of the risks and take precautions to protect themselves from potential liability.

“This legislation was pushed through claiming they were urgently needed to target violent and dangerous content, but unlike prohibitions against CSAM or revenge porn, the laws target legal, consensual sexual activity between adults,” says Boden. “This is a frightening precedent for free speech and sexual freedom. We will continue to guide our members as more information and resources become available.”

 

Read More »