UK flag

Is the UK Going to Criminalize Adult Creators for ‘Exploiting’ Themselves? By Stan Q. Brick

As you already know if you’re a regular reader of this site, a group of MPs in the United Kingdom is calling for the criminalization of adult webcamming, terming it “e-pimping” and asserting that “harms relating to the webcamming trade are severe and wide-ranging, affecting all women and girls – whether they are directly involved in the trade or not.”

The claim that adult webcamming harms all women is the sort of sweeping assertion we always hear when it comes to sexually explicit expression, which to hear the most zealous decency crusaders tell it has been absolutely ruining society since the inception of pornography, back when prehistoric humans began scrawling dick pics on the walls of caves.

As someone who has spent over half his life working in the adult industry, I’m not going to sit here and claim exploitation never happens in this line of work. Frankly, it would be insane to claim any industry is free of exploitation.

Where I strongly dispute the findings of the All-Party Group on Commercial Sexual Exploitation (APGCSE), the name for the group of MPs who are calling for webcamming to be outlawed, is the notion that the technology and camming industry vertical are inherently exploitative or necessarily making things worse.

For starters, modern adult performers and content creators have a vastly increased number of options for how they work within the adult industry compared to earlier generations. The days of a handful of adult studios or a few dozen online companies serving as publishing gatekeepers are long gone.

Whether webcam networks and platforms like OnlyFans and its competitors are exploiting their creators by taking too large a slice of the sales revenue, selectively enforcing their content policies, selectively shadowbanning people or any other sort of poor corporate behavior likely varies from site to site – and opinions of those platforms among creators certainly vary quite a bit, as well.

One gets the sense that would-be censors like the APGCSE aren’t particularly interested in nuance or distinguishing between good and bad corporate citizens among adult platforms, though. They’re convinced of their moral superiority and the righteousness of their paternalistic orientation to the point they’re not going to hesitate to toss out the creators’ personal income baby along with the platform’s allegedly exploitative bathwater.

I’d also point out that while the APGCSE report makes repeated reference to OnlyFans and to webcamming platforms (News Flash: camming is not exactly the core of OnlyFans’ business), many of the specific examples of alleged exploitation highlighted in the report involve OnlyFans management agencies – or indeed, individual managers.

The report is a bit more persuasive in the sections describing sexual exploitation by studios, abusive partners and viewers – but again, the things described in those sections are already illegal. Cracking down directly on companies and individuals who exploit performers seems a more promising approach to addressing the problems cited in the report, as it can be done without punishing the creators, managers, agencies, studios, viewers and others who aren’t engaging in those crimes.

There’s no question OnlyFans and platforms like it have their issues. But they’re also places where a lot of women (and men and trans folk) are earning good money on their own images and content. I suppose the APGCSE might respond that even if a creator is performing each sex act willingly, they are still engaged in an act of self-exploitation, which is harming them in ways of which they may not be aware – in addition to damaging everyone else in society, as the APGCSE report asserts right up front.

But should this sort of “self-exploitation” truly be a government’s concern? If so, does the UK government also have a paternalistic role to play in regulating entertainment like football? People sometimes DIE from playing that game, after all. And just like its American football counterpart, the game most of the rest of the world calls football produces a whole lot of concussions.

To be clear, I’m not calling for the UK to ban football. Among other things, if they do that, I’ll have a lot less to look forward to over the course of nine months of each year, even though for me, watching the Premier League sometimes means getting up at 4:30am on a Saturday.

All I’m saying, again, is that if you believe women are full human beings, with independent agency and a right to self-determination, then it makes no sense to deprive them of options for employment, competition, income generation, entertainment or any other facet of life, under reasoning of the sort we never seem to apply to men.

Certainly, we should all be against exploitation. But there are smart and effective ways to fight exploitation and there are overreaching, one-size-fits-all, censorship campaigns masquerading as anti-exploitation efforts. If you’ve read this far, you already know which sort of campaign I believe APGCSE to be waging.

About thewaronporn

The War on Porn was created because of the long standing assault on free speech in the form of sexual expression that is porn and adult content.

Check Also

Big Ben

U.K. Begins Enforcing Criminal Prohibitions on ‘Taboo’ Pornography

LONDON—British law enforcement and regulatory agencies are beginning enforcement of new prohibitions on several categories …