INDIANAPOLIS — An Indiana judge has dismissed a lawsuit brought by Republican Attorney General Todd Rokita against Aylo, the parent company of Pornhub.com, and several affiliated businesses.
Rokita filed the lawsuit last December against Aylo and its ownership group, Ottawa-based Ethical Capital Partners, alleging that the companies violated Indiana’s age-verification law (AVL) by failing to prevent users from bypassing geographic restrictions through virtual private networks (VPNs), which can mask a user’s actual location.
The case was filed in Marion Superior Court in Indianapolis. In March, Aylo’s attorneys sought dismissal of the lawsuit, challenging the claims brought by Rokita’s office.
Judge Patrick J. Dietrick dismissed all claims brought by the attorney general’s office, including allegations that Aylo and its affiliated platforms failed to restrict access to users located in Indiana when VPNs or proxy servers were used to make their IP addresses appear to originate outside the state.
Rokita’s office argued that VPNs provide minors with a means of accessing content otherwise restricted under Indiana’s age-verification requirements. However, the state did not establish that VPN use constituted a violation of the law, a point addressed in Dietrick’s ruling.
“An AVL claim requires facts showing that the defendant (1) owns or operates a publicly accessible website (2) on which at least one-third of the images and videos depict material harmful to minors, (3) knowingly or intentionally publishes it, and (4) does not use a reasonable age verification method,” Dietrick wrote.
“The AVL contains no provision based on a user’s physical location and none addressing VPNs or proxy servers, and courts ‘may not add new words to a statute which are not the expressed intent of the legislature,'” he added.
During the investigation preceding the lawsuit, an investigator working for Rokita’s office used a commercially available VPN service to make the internet connection appear to originate in Chicago. The judge’s ruling also addressed the implications of that test for the state’s claims and its attempt to establish jurisdiction in Indiana.
“The claim against Aylo Premium and Aylo Social fails for the same reason,” Dietrick explained. “Every alleged instance of access to a paysite or marketplace site came through a Chicago IP address.”
He further wrote, “The state’s theory that defendants know VPNs can defeat IP-based restrictions alleges at most general awareness that geolocation sometimes fails, not knowledge that a particular user presenting an Illinois IP address is physically in Indiana.”
“On the facts the Complaint itself pleads, no operator knowingly or intentionally published adult content without age verification to a user it identified as being in Indiana, and the Complaint identifies no defect in what Aylo Premium or Aylo Social presents to such users,” Dietrick concluded.
A spokesperson for Aylo was contacted for comment but had not responded by the time of publication.
The War on Porn Regular Updates about the Assault on The Adult Industry