Texas flag

Federal Judge Weighs Challenge to Texas Pornography Health Warning Law

AUSTIN, Texas — Competing motions for summary judgment have been filed in a federal court in Texas over a state law requiring age verification on adult websites and mandating health warnings about pornography, with both sides seeking a ruling from the judge on the law’s constitutionality.

The filings were submitted by adult industry plaintiffs challenging the state and by the office of outgoing Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton. Both sides are seeking a decision from U.S. District Judge David Alan Ezra, a Reagan-era appointee.

The dispute stems from the original court proceedings in 2023 and involves Texas House Bill 1181, the state’s age-verification law. The legislation reached the U.S. Supreme Court in 2025, where justices upheld the constitutionality of age verification. However, litigation continued in Texas over other provisions of the law, including its requirements for websites beyond the age-gating provisions.

The latest proceedings involve a challenge brought by the Free Speech Coalition (FSC), an adult industry trade association, along with parent companies of several major adult tube sites. The plaintiffs are contesting HB 1181’s age-verification provisions and its requirement that adult websites display public health warnings about the purported effects of pornography consumption.

Earlier in the case, Judge Ezra, a senior judge in the Western District of Texas, found that the mandated health warnings likely violated the First and Fourteenth Amendments. The ruling centered on the disputed nature of the claims the law requires websites to communicate.

Courts evaluating government-mandated speech by private businesses apply legal standards to determine whether such requirements are permissible. One of those tests is the Zauderer standard, which examines when the government can compel commercial speech without infringing on First Amendment protections.

Under HB 1181, adult websites accessible to Texas users would be required to display health-related warnings intended to inform visitors about alleged risks associated with pornography consumption.

The law requires adult websites with users in Texas to prominently display the mandated public health warnings. Lawmakers included language asserting potential health consequences associated with pornography use, similar to warnings placed on alcohol, cigarette and vaping products.

Judge Ezra previously struck down the warning requirements, citing concerns that they failed to satisfy the Zaudererstandard. Under that test, compelled disclosures must be “purely factual and uncontroversial.”

Ezra found that the warnings did not meet that threshold, noting the absence of a recognized medical diagnosis for pornography addiction and a lack of sufficient scientific evidence supporting the claims included in the mandated notices. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that portion of his ruling. In their latest filing, the FSC and other plaintiffs are asking Ezra to grant summary judgment based on his earlier findings.

“The requirement of HB 1181 to post health warnings and a helpline notice is not a valid exercise of the state’s power to regulate speech (commercial or otherwise), and Texas cannot constitutionally turn adult websites into government billboards waging its own war against adult content,” the attorneys for the adult industry plaintiffs argue. “The court should enter summary judgment for the plaintiffs.”

Attorneys for Paxton’s office take a different position, citing research and testimony from anti-pornography advocates in support of the law’s disputed health claims. Court filings show the state relied on academics, including political scientist Vanessa Bouché, who co-authored research with other anti-pornography scholars published in the journal Dignity.

The journal has faced criticism over its academic standards and research practices, as well as controversy surrounding editor-in-chief Donna M. Hughes, a University of Rhode Island professor of gender and women’s studies who has been accused of anti-trans views. Other experts retained by Paxton’s office include feminist activist Gail Dines, founder of Culture Reframed, a group associated with anti-pornography advocacy.

The FSC and other plaintiffs have countered with experts who say the scientific evidence does not support the health warnings required by the law. Dr. Joshua Grubbs, an associate professor of psychology at the University of New Mexico, wrote in a report submitted on behalf of the plaintiffs that the warnings contain “a veritable cavalcade of misconceptions, misdirection, and false claims.”

“In my expert opinion, the inclusion of such warnings would likely be actively harmful to users of such adult websites, as it would promote false beliefs about pornography use and sexual behavior that would likely lead to feelings of distress and confusion among users,” Grubbs wrote.

Attorney Corey Silverstein, who represents adult industry clients, said he expects the plaintiffs to prevail on their request for summary judgment.

“Once a visitor has verified that they’re an adult, how does requiring a mental health and substance use helpline on every page they visit keep a child from seeing the content? I think the court should make the injunction against the warnings permanent,” Silverstein said.

The FSC’s co-plaintiffs, WebGroup Czech Republic and NKL Associates, which own and operate Xvideos and XNXX, have also asked the court to rule that both the health warning and age-verification provisions of HB 1181 violate the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause because they conflict with Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996.

“The Fifth Circuit already reasoned that the state can impose liability for a platform’s own failure to check a visitor’s age without proving that anyone was harmed by a user’s upload,” Silverstein concluded. “That’s why I expect a split ruling, with the warnings blocked and the age-verification requirement still in force.”

About thewaronporn

The War on Porn was created because of the long standing assault on free speech in the form of sexual expression that is porn and adult content.

Check Also

UK flag

U.K. Lawmakers Push to Criminalize Camming, Calling It ‘E-pimping’

LONDON—A new report from a group of U.K. parliamentarians is calling for online camming platforms …